Reviews
powered by
5.0
...
...
Best cakes in NYC. Hands down.
May 10, 2026
Leslie Garrett
AMAZING. Best cake I hav ever had finally in NYC out of Harlem. Strawberry cake was so moist and the strawberry preserve was so fresh and the... Read more
May 2, 2026
DaShawn Thomas
Apr 23, 2026
Adrienne Nunley
I recently ordered the Ultimate Strawberry for my wife’s birthday and it was beautiful and delicious! Cant wait to try morw!
Mar 22, 2026
Jose Bahamonde
I ordered the triple chocolate cake slice. It was amazing. You can tell so much care went into it. I would definitely order again.
Mar 20, 2026
jemarle riley
I have ordered from here on Uber Eats multiple times. I am the biggest cake snob and only like it from here or a place in BK as I find every other... Read more
Mar 7, 2026
elly hull
Contact Gardners Gourmet Baking Co
Send us an email